“Joe Caskey, with his smooth, rich tones, delivers an emotional, goose-bump-worthy performance of "Kiss of the Spiderwoman" and "We Can Make It."
— Angie Stanton, BroadwayWorld.com
“Caskey… delivers the seven and a half-minute operatic “Soliloquy” that closes the first act with fantastic flair.”
— Brandy McDonnell, oklahoman.com
“Joe Caskey is swarthy and sinister as leading man Billy Bigelow.”
— Adrienne Proctor, broadwayworld.com